CBS-47 (Fresno, California)

February 9, 2009

 

Farm Workers Demand Apology from Environmentalist

Farm workers and their families rallied on the steps of Fresno City Hall on Monday, after controversial statements were made by a leading environmentalist. They are now demanding an apology.

Lloyd Carter with the California Water Impact Network made the statement last week after a public debate on water policy at Fresno State. Carter said, “They’re not even American citizens for starters, right? Do you think that we should employ illegal aliens? What parent raises their child to become a farmworker? These kids, they’re the least educated people in America or in the southwest corner of this Valley. They turn to lives or crime, they go on welfare, they get into drug trafficking and they join gangs.”

The farming community has now turned the focus of the debate from water rights and the protection of the delta smelt to they statements made by Carter. They feel his statements show how divided the debate has become and how the environmentalists care more about a fish than for the people of the Valley.

Mayors from rural Valley communities like Firebaugh, Mendota along with Congressman Devin Nunes and Assemblyman Juan Arambula condemned Carter’s statements at the Monday rally. They also condemned those they call “radical environmentalists” who are preventing the farmers from accessing the delta water need to save their crops in order to protect the fish known as the delta smelt.

Congressman Nunes says without the water, 500,000 acres of farmland will be out of production and 40,000 jobs will be lost.

Congressman Nunes said, “Those 40,000 jobs folks are going to come from the people behind me and all around you from Fresno to Bakersfield. That’s where those 40,000 people, that are employed now, are not going to have work.”

Congressman Nunes is also advising Congress to support the Drought Alleviation Act that is now being sponsored by Congressman George Radanovich. That act would alleviate restrictions on water to farmers in times of drought.

Lloyd Carter has since issued a written apology on his internet blog that says, “My remarks were intended to focus on the social costs of exploiting an immigrant worker population which is denied adequate pay, housing and education. I now realize I made a terrible mistake in the way I expressed myself and I humbly apologize to all who were offended. Again I painfully realize my comments offended many people and truly regret the error. It will not happen again. I am sick about this.”

The California Water Impact Network is a privately funded environmental group.